62 Wooster, LLC v. TML N.Y. Inc. (Good Guy Guaranty Surrender Dispute)

The Appellate Division, First Department affirmed dismissal of a SoHo landlord's claims against the individual guarantors of a retail lease at 476 Broome Street, holding their liability ended when the tenant physically vacated the premises in 2020 notwithstanding a separate lease provision tying liability to a later, formally defined 'Surrender Date.' The court applied the Court of Appeals' 2025 decision in 1995 CAM LLC v. West Side Advisors, which construed 'surrender' in a guaranty to mean the tenant's physical relinquishment of possession, not a landlord's acceptance or a later contractual milestone. The ruling forecloses the landlord's claims for roughly $307,577.08 in unpaid rent plus liquidated damages and enforcement costs against the guarantors.

Why it matters

Good guy guaranties are a standard risk-mitigation tool in New York City commercial leasing, and this decision confirms courts will resolve internal conflicts in guaranty release language in favor of the simpler, vacatur-based trigger, even where a landlord's drafting attempted to extend liability through a more technical defined term. Landlords relying on multi-layered 'Surrender Date' concepts to keep guarantors on the hook past actual move-out should reconcile that language with any surrender-based release clause before the next lease is signed, not after a tenant has already left.

Case timeline · 3 entries Latest: October 1, 2026 — Appellate Division, First Department affirms dismissal of the landlord's claims against the guarantors

Looking for something else?

Search the litigation tracker

Search

More commercial lease disputes matters

• Salha and Abu Ali Cafe v. 2020 Harwin 59 Shopping Centers (Restaurant Lease Repair and Sublease Dispute)October 16, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Commercial Properties, Inc. v. Montgomery Civic Ballet, Inc. (Commercial Lease Default, Indemnity and Untimely Opposition)October 16, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• First Department Affirms $1.2 Million Jury Verdict for Preschool Tenant Against Bohemian Brethren Presbyterian Church Over Uncleared Building ViolationsOctober 13, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Pacific Collective, LLC v. TGS CC Ventures, LLC: California Appeals Court Holds Build-to-Suit Landlord's Slow Land Purchase Let Jushi Unit Rescind Culver City Dispensary LeaseOctober 12, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Dunnavant Valley Dining LLC v. PRG Valley Post: $7.19 Million Default Judgment for Unpaid Rent at Chelsea, Alabama's Valley Post Dining DevelopmentOctober 7, 2026 · Ruling Issued

Other matters in New York

• Waterworks Operating Co., LLC v. 514 W. 24th Owner LLC (Mechanic's-Lien and Breach-of-Contract Judgment Partly Vacated on Appeal)October 15, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• CFS Enterprises, Inc. v. CG & J Realty, LLC (Queens Mechanic's Lien Bond Dispute)October 14, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Quinlan Development Group v. Maple 1 Farley Owner LLC (Penn Plaza Life-Sciences Site Foreclosure)October 13, 2026 · Filed
• In re AZ 175th Street LLC: Queens Mixed-Use Owner Files Second Chapter 11 After First Case Was Dismissed With a Refiling BarOctober 10, 2026 · Filed
• Computershare Trust (BMO 2024-5C5) v. Starwood Mortgage Capital: $46.85M CMBS Loan Repurchase Suit Removed to Federal Court Over Undisclosed Senior LienOctober 9, 2026 · Pending

Recently added

• Salha and Abu Ali Cafe v. 2020 Harwin 59 Shopping Centers (Restaurant Lease Repair and Sublease Dispute)October 16, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Deutsche Bank Moves Toward Foreclosure on Vacant Former eBay Campus in San JoseOctober 15, 2026 · Filed
• Jefferies LoanCore Declares Default on Archer Aviation-Anchored North San Jose Office CampusOctober 13, 2026 · Filed
• ACORE Capital Declares Default on GPI Companies' West End Office CampusOctober 12, 2026 · Filed
• Freddie Mac v. Nord Group Affiliate (Edgewater Apartments Post-Foreclosure Rent Diversion Dispute)October 15, 2026 · Pending

CREdocket summarizes public court records and reporting; see our sourcing standards and corrections log. Not legal advice. Facing something similar? Contact us.