USPA City Center, LLC v. Law Offices of Jason W. Estavillo, P.C.: California Court Publishes Ruling Upholding $1.2M Future-Rent Award on Oakland Office Lease

A California appeals court published its ruling upholding $1,219,015.63 in future rent for the landlord of 555 12th Street in Oakland against a defaulted law-firm office tenant.

On October 19, 2026, the California Court of Appeal ordered its September 21 opinion in USPA City Center, LLC v. Law Offices of Jason W. Estavillo, P.C. published, which makes it binding precedent. The opinion affirmed an Alameda County judgment giving the landlord of 555 12th Street in downtown Oakland $350,677.82 in back rent and holdover damages and $1,219,015.63 in future rent, discounted to present value, against a law-firm tenant that defaulted months into a 66-month office lease. The court rejected the tenant's arguments that the future-rent award lacked evidence, was a penalty, and paid the landlord twice.

Why it matters

There is now published California authority that a landlord can recover several years of future rent under Civil Code section 1951.2 when it proves, through broker testimony and vacancy data, that the space cannot realistically be re-let. The record describes the downtown Oakland office market as weak, which gives landlords in similar markets a model for proving rental losses the tenant could not have avoided. The court also held that a stipulated judgment for future rent is not a penalty when it only restates what the lease and the Civil Code already allow.

Case timeline · 6 entries Latest: October 19, 2026 — Opinion certified for publication

Looking for something else?

Search the litigation tracker

Search

More commercial lease disputes matters

• Colliers International NY LLC v. City Hall Commons LLC: First Department Affirms $307,326 Commission Judgment Against Landlord on Lease RenewalOctober 22, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Lot 2 SBO, LLC v. Twitter, Inc. n/k/a X Corp.: Colorado Appeals Court Reverses $8.2M Boulder Office Rent Judgment Over Tenant-Improvement Rent CreditOctober 22, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Crocker Park, L.L.C. v. City of Westlake, Ohio (Right of First Refusal Revived on Reconsideration)October 22, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• VK Dental Group, Inc. v. Tender Touch Physical Therapy, PLLC (NY Appellate Division Revives $1M Sublease Rent Dispute)October 21, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• 513 West 26th Realty LLC v. George Billis Galleries, Inc. (Guaranty Law Contracts Clause Ruling)October 20, 2026 · Ruling Issued

Other matters in California

• Joseph F. Farivar Investment Group, Inc. v. HPC Vineburn, LLC (Groundwater Contamination Judgment Reversed)October 22, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• The Waffle, LLC v. Tucker Investment Group, LLC (Westwood Restaurant Lease Arbitration Affirmed)October 19, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Deutsche Bank Moves Toward Foreclosure on Vacant Former eBay Campus in San JoseOctober 15, 2026 · Filed
• Jefferies LoanCore Declares Default on Archer Aviation-Anchored North San Jose Office CampusOctober 13, 2026 · Filed
• ACORE Capital Declares Default on GPI Companies' West End Office CampusOctober 12, 2026 · Filed

Recently added

• Colliers International NY LLC v. City Hall Commons LLC: First Department Affirms $307,326 Commission Judgment Against Landlord on Lease RenewalOctober 22, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• BSC Realty Services, LLC v. Valcourt Building Services of Georgia, L.C.: Georgia Appeals Court Revives Building Manager's Indemnity Claim Over Rooftop Cooling-Tower FallOctober 19, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Whidbey Environmental Action Network v. City of Oak Harbor: Washington Appeals Court Revives SEPA Challenge to Park-Land Ordinance Passed for a 107-Room Home2 Suites HotelOctober 19, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• State v. 101 Franklin Derry, LLC: New Hampshire Jury Upholds Eminent Domain Takings of Developer's Land for I-93 Exit 4AOctober 20, 2026 · Ruling Issued
• Sierra Club v. Wisconsin Department of Natural Resources: Settlement Leaves Vantage's $15 Billion Port Washington Data Center Permits Intact and Has Vantage Fund a Statewide Data Center Impact StudyOctober 16, 2026 · Settled

CREdocket summarizes public court records and reporting; see our sourcing standards and corrections log. Not legal advice. Facing something similar? Contact us.